Where in my post did I say that McIlrath was taking too long to develop? I'm not sure what people are reading.
He's right about where he needs to be after one injury shortened year. I've grown to love this pick. Especially right after a series like the one we just had.
No one respects the Rangers as a physical team. Their back line is competent. Sure, they finish their checks and initiate quite a few. They can shut down goal scorers. But the Rangers intimidate no one. They can not win series long physical battles of attrition over teams like Boston, Pittsburgh or L.A.. We've seen this now for two play off runs in consecutive years. I'm amazed this is not focused on more often. The Rangers are not soft but they can not beat you in the alley. Come play off time you had better be able to with stand that as well as dish it out.
McIlrath is the beginning of an answer to this ongoing problem.
Absolutely agree with everything you said here. The tough players we have (Asham, Dorsett-even Haley) are smaller tough players. No Chris Neil's--No Milan Lucic's. No Chara's on the back end. That's pretty much why a lot of people were excited about Clowe (not a great skater but a big forward with some skill and a lot of mean). Looking at how Toronto came out of nowhere but Orr, McLaren and Martin kept every team in the league honest. The best teams have a mix of skill and toughness. The players fit comfortably into their roles but they also there are teammates that will have their backs if push comes to shove. It's evident that Boston is one of those teams (Chara, Lucic, Thornton, McQuaid) and Pittsburgh is another.
What's the book on Yogan at this point? Has he developed in Hartford, or likely career AHLer?
Originally Posted by Kwayry
He has the size, grit, skating, hands and vision to play at the next level. Pretty good at FO's too. Needs more seasoning though. I suspect he will get a cup of tea next season.
Originally Posted by Joey Bones
This. He looked decently in the AHL this year. He'll get a look in camp, but needs time yet.
He missed a significant chunk of major development time with an injury which was unfortunate. He has the skills, size and skating to be an effective bottom-6 player but the issue prior to this season, was that he was not effective unless getting big minutes. He had problems engaging when given 10-12 minutes a game.
He was sent down to the ECHL due to the depth that started the year in Hartford and the fact that he needed lots of minutes. He found his game down there with almost a ppg and then came back up and was effective using his body and driving hard to the net. That is when he is effective. He has to drive tot he net with his size and strength.
I would say he needs at least another full year in the AHL and to get to ~ 40-45 points at least. He also needs to continue to get stronger and play with a bit of a mean streak to have a shot of moving up and like all young players, consistency is key.
I was high on him when he was drafted so maybe I am a bit biased, but I think the Rangers have a future NHLer on their hands with Yogan.
It's not even 3 years since that draft, relax, just goes to show how awful youe evalutions can be, you think 3 years is the perfect time to measure a drafts worth. You need to stick to the NFL. .
I think 3 years is plenty of time to review the 1st round in. Gudbranson, Fowler, Burmi, Johansen, and Nino all look like they will be mediocre players. Skinner has slowed down since his great rookie year.
Tarasenko looks like a decent player but far from a superstar.
Not saying the draft sucks. But I considered it one of the deepest drafts in years. I think it will produce a lot of decent - solid players, but not the large amount of top line guys it looked like it had.
"Of course giving Sather cap space is like giving teenagers whiskey and car keys." - SBOB "Watching Sather build a team is like watching a blind man with no fingers trying to put together an elaborate puzzle." - Shadowtron
"Used to be only Twinkies and cockroaches could survive a nuke. I'd add Habs to that. I'm convinced the CH stands for Club du Hypocrisy." - Gee Wally
What's your definition of mediocre? Seems a bit harsh.
How is it harsh? I think those guys look to be capping out as 2nd/3rd liners. The draft was supposed to be loaded with top line players and multiple stars. I certainly thought so when I was scouting it.
It's "only" three years out and a lot can change, but I'm not sure if it will.
We're getting a large number of bodies for our forward corps next year on the wolfpack. Just let him walk.
I'd rather sign him to an AHL deal and then loan him to Greenville. Maybe you catch lightning in a bottle and the kid turns it on, and forces his way into the AHL and eventually an NHL deal. No downside to giving him an AHL deal, really.
If Dan Hobbs and Max Campbell can get AHL deals, McColgan should get one as well.
While McColgan seems to have stalled in terms of offense, I would still be interested in keeping him. He plays with an edge and while he's smaller in stature, he is quite good at getting opposing forwards off their game. He's easily worth an AHL deal on that alone, IMO. A bit surprised by this.