Honestly, if you asked before the playoffs, I'd say Ryan. Lucic has been coasting around for a while now and didn't seem to care. This year in the playoffs he really stepped it up and went back to his overly physical self. Seeing him in the playoffs this year makes me pick Lucic. But, if he goes back to how he was in the regular season again or how he was at any point last year (playoffs included,) I'd take Ryan.
In Philly I would rather want Ryan, we don't need Lucic. And Bobby Ryan is one of my favourite non-Flyers players so I would be pleased to see him in Philly jersey. I definitely wouldn't mind if Homer trade for him. Ryan - Giroux - Voracek would be awesome top line.
Ducks fan voting Lucic. Ryan will probably always outproduce Lucic in the regular season, and will sometimes even outproduce him by a wide margin, but that extra element that Lucic brings is so vital to a team in the playoffs, it's easily worth the tradeoff.
I voted Lucic but I'm taking it on faith that he won't again float through a regular season quite as bad as he did this year. I like Ryan, but his impact on a game is not the same as Lucic's, even if he produces a bit more.