Quote:
Originally Posted by combine81
I don't regard Voynov as a high end prospect either. I mentioned him just because Hockeycritic had said that Petrov is a phenomenon because he made his debut in RSL at 16 years of age.
As for Lazarev. He should play and doesn't think about money. Now he's wasting his time while Traktor and Khimik fight for him. Just IMO. Lazarev was the best player in Khimik-2 during pre-season.
|
THANKS a lot for very interesting discussion and facts. Let's do some disticnctions between 2 words PHENOMENON and WUNDERKIND not to create mix-up! OK?
Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate DICTIONARY:
WUN-DER-KIND n, pl wun-der-kin-der (G, Fr Wunder wonder+ kind child) a child Prodigy; also: One who succeeds in competitive or highly difficult field or profession at an early age!
PHE-NOM-E-NON n-pl, -na (LL Phaenomenon) 1. An observable fact or event. 2. A rare or significant fact or event. An exceptional or abnormal person, thing or occurrence.
Collins Birmingham University Dictionary:
A PHENOMENON is something that is observed to happen or exists…
To my mind WUNDERKINDS of Russian hockey are D Tverdovsky Krylia Soviets M debut at 16 92-93, FW Samsonov 1978 CSKA M debut at 16 94/95, D/FW Markov Andrei Voskresensk debut at 17 95-96, FW Malkin Magnitogorsk debut at 17 03-04, FW Afinogenov Dynamo M at 16 95-96, Ovechkin debut at 16 01-02.
6 persons in 10-15 years. Of course, OVECHKIN and MALKIN stand-out of this group for sure!
In Soviet times 16 years of age DEBUT was considered normal but different times and league played lesser games. Now in Russian times many teams put onto the roster YOUNG players not becausethey are MEGA SKILLED but because of different problems crowd of injured players or financial crisis...
ARTIFICIAL measured not NATURAL like with those 6 players I mentioned.
ARTIFICIAL case of: D Markov Daniil SPARTAK M 93-94 debut at 17 who was quite late NHL pick but surprisingly developed into EXCELLENT NHL defenseman EXCEPTION OF THE RULES!
Quite not easy period for Russian Hockey 93/94 in financial terms. Modern times somebody mentioned FW Plyuschev 1986 Spartak M 01-02 debut at 15 years of age. Nothing of the kind that we can talk EVEN about phenomenon case. TRAGEDY financial tragedy of the club and that's it. Happiness for Plyuschev because his father could even help him with DEBUT that time. BTW this player still can't skate. Runs onto the heels of his skates which is funny.
Who else we have not discussed? Oh, YES, D EZHOV 1985 01-02 debut at 16 with Togliatti which had also problems in the club with DEFENSIVE corpus! Artificial measure. Then D SELEZNEV Yakov 1989 04-05 debut at 15 in PERM, FW REPKIN Alexei late born 1987 04-05 debut at 17 with PERM which is in financial crisis and experienced players will not take the job for nothing. KOROSTIN Sergei 1989 05-06 Dynamo M debut at 16 just because of too many injured players onto the roster. D VOINOV 1990 06-07 debut at 16 with CHELYABINSK is ARTIFICIAL measure as coach Tsygurov comments though VOINOV isn't bad player. Chelaybisnk can't buy experienced players and that explains everything...
Too many factors must be taken into consideration and before uttering a word you must yourself see the player onto the ice at least 2-3 times to understand his LEVEL.
INTERESTING Sporting Newspaper Soviet-Sport 12 March 2005 regarding topic wonderkinds or phenomenons. JUST FOR FUN TO READ!
LINK:
http://www.sovsport.ru/gazeta/default.asp?id=181855
Quite and interesting NOTE Soviet-Sport newspaper on January 19, 2006 about the other young player born 1989 who played CSKA M vs Dynamo M 2-1 game
LINK:
http://www.sovsport.ru/gazeta/defaul...1/19&id=211254
Из-за загруженности динамовского лазарета на лед вышел игрок, которому лишь недавно исполнилось 16 лет. Имя вундеркинда – Сергей Коростин. Он стал самым молодым хоккеистом нынешнего первенства, но до рекорда прошлого сезона не дотянул: Яков Селезнев сыграл свой первый матч за «Молот» в возрасте 15 лет и 4 месяца.
Link SEVEZNEV interview in Russian:
http://russia.thehockeyworld.com/molot/1.html
PERTOV Kirill so far 'an observable fact or event' PHENOMENON in other word and I hope sonner or later he must switch into WUNDERKIND category because KAZAN isn't the team which has problems with ROSTER or finance. SAME thing concerns KITSYN in NOVOKUZNETSK!