Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Trottier
Message to STBOB (the only NYR poster on this thread with more than a shred of objectivity and hockey knowledge):
One team's goon is another team's enforcer. (You know, the old, "he's on my team, he's not a dirty player!")
A solid case can be made for Doull being a no-talent goon. The very same case can be made for NYR's neanderthal on D. Yes, he fights, but he also jumps players, including Jason Blake from behind a couple seasons back. (Just awaiting the justification regarding that one from the hypocrite, er, fan who was ripping Peca last week for being a dity player  and suddenly is calling for NYR justice tonight!  )
Steve Webb rarely registered a point with NYI, and he drove opponents nuts as he's step on the ice and start hurling his body at players, a vast majority of the time legally. Should he be thrown out of the league? Tootoo? Others?
Slippery slope, one that would certainly include some of the hometown favorites.
***
If some of the video experts :p here spent 1/10 of the time studying the Zapruder film as they do studying slow-mo video of split second on-ice hits (and subsequently coming to ridiculous conclusions as a result), the JFK assassination would have been a shut and closed case decades ago! 
|
I'm quite aware that that one man's goon is another man's enforcer.
I have seen Dale Purinton pull some of the worst acts there out there. And he was a disgrace then. Since then, he has managed to tone it down a bit (and now he is only a disgrace because he can't skate :p ). And to the point of Jason Blake, can you really blame DP? That little SOB bothers the hell out of me! Love to have him on my team.
Webb might have rarely registered a point but he was a tenacious worker, fairly intelligent player who would get under other teams skin by working hard and throwing the big hits (while still being willing to drop the gloves). And he drew penalties.
Again, the most telling part, IMO is that Doull somehow managed to register 80 PIMs in a staggaring and exhausting :38 of ice time yesterday.
**********
And I did see Nedved's head go back...and the left, back...and the left, back...and the left.

Thanks for the kind words and laugh Trotts.
With that, I'm done with this thread. Parting is such sweet sorrow. And so is being a Ranger fan.