I loved Hextall too. But his best season was his first one in '86-87. He was a first team all-star, a Vezina Trophy winner and a Conn Smythe winner. After that he had sketchy play. He never played in the Canada Cup '87 although he backed up Fuhr. hen he had some sub-par years in Philly. If he had two mroe great seasons like that then I'd sya yeah, but he didnt. No Hall of Fame.
I don't know about the Hall of Fame. Hextall had a pretty uneven career and he wasn't held in very high regard at the end of his career when he was putting up his best statistics. Actually, definitely no Hall of Fame as far as I'm concerned.