Past & Present NHL Punching Bags

[kento19]

Greg "Bird Dog" Smith anyone? Lots of respect since he continously fought the toughest guys in the league such as Probert, but has the guy ever won a fight?

On a side note, never knew there was a rematch between boulerice and downey. Boulerice definitely got him back.

[Bi Coastal Bawse]

Originally Posted by pigpen65

Has Gregory Campbell ever won a fight?

Against Pyatt vs. Montreal

maybe against LaPierre but that fight was pathetic

all Campbell does is spin around and aimlessly throw punches

[LeanBeef]

Weise, Crombeen, G. Campbell, and basically everyone Bieksa fights(sorry Juice).

[Trognitz]

Originally Posted by pigpen65

Has Gregory Campbell ever won a fight?

takes after Colon

[cashman rules]

Magnuson
Buchberger
Tucker
Marini
Odgers
Russell
Dingman
Barnaby
Gill
Kypreos
Trembley
Reichel
Schenn

[CHGoalie72]

Say what you want about Greg Campbell, but he's one of the toughest players in the modern era.

I take Greg Campbell and Ryan Callahan as my first two choices of PK forwards.

[capebretoncanadien]

Originally Posted by CHGoalie72

Say what you want about Greg Campbell, but he's one of the toughest players in the modern era.

I take Greg Campbell and Ryan Callahan as my first two choices of PK forwards.

Wow that's pushing it. He's rugged I'll give you that. One of the toughest players of the modern era? Just no.

[BlackNgold 84]

Originally Posted by CHGoalie72

Say what you want about Greg Campbell, but he's one of the toughest players in the modern era.

I take Greg Campbell and Ryan Callahan as my first two choices of PK forwards.

uhhh no.. i like campbell and i don't think hes as horrible as people have made him out to be.. but he isn't one of the toughest players in the modern era.

[moolah3i4]

Present: Marc Staal vs. Alex Semin, nahh im jk lol

[Mynameismark*]

Originally Posted by cashman rules

Magnuson
Buchberger
Tucker
Marini
Odgers
Russell
Dingman
Barnaby
Gill
Kypreos
Trembley
Reichel
Schenn

Tucker wasn't a punching bag at all.

[Mynameismark*]

Matt Cooke has always been pretty bad and he knows it.

Daryl Bootland

[WildcatMapleLeafs28]

Past : Matt Barnaby. Honestly don't recall him ever winning a fight and he fought alot.

Present: Konopka or Tim Jackman

most overrated : George Laraque a.k.a bear hugger

[cashman rules]

Originally Posted by Mynameismark

Tucker wasn't a punching bag at all.

Bled like a stuck pig most of the time,kinda like Rinaldo.

[Trognitz]

Originally Posted by cashman rules

Bled like a stuck pig most of the time,kinda like Rinaldo.

got hammered by Steve Webb whom most call a punching bag.

[thom]

Eddie Shack of the leafs.Dave tiger Williams who would fight anyone anywhere but problay lost more than he won.Tiger hated losers on his team and would do any thing to win

[Mynameismark*]

Originally Posted by Trognitz

got hammered by Steve Webb whom most call a punching bag.

He never lost to Webb in a fight as they never fought, and if they had Webb would lose.

Also he bled at times, mostly not from fighting. Dude was 178 pounds and beat guys much bigger than him.

[Trognitz]

Originally Posted by Mynameismark

He never lost to Webb in a fight as they never fought, and if they had Webb would lose.

Also he bled at times, mostly not from fighting. Dude was 178 pounds and beat guys much bigger than him.

allright zippy, i'll try to find the clip and prove u to be 'lost'.

[cashman rules]

Originally Posted by Mynameismark

He never lost to Webb in a fight as they never fought, and if they had Webb would lose.

Also he bled at times, mostly not from fighting. Dude was 178 pounds and beat guys much bigger than him.

Cam Janssen,Kilger,Boullion,Ruutu all busted him open in wins but i don't recall Webb

[Trognitz]

Originally Posted by cashman rules

Cam Janssen,Kilger,Boullion,Ruutu all busted him open in wins but i don't recall Webb

evidently i WAS mistaken and thanx for pointing out. upon closer look it WASNT Tucker, not sure who it was. Roberts ? if so, certainly a better fighter than Tucker. at appx 2:30 mark. sincere apologies, it was a short segment and i assumed it was Tucker trying to get payback from the devastating hit Webb destroyed him with.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o7f0RTedfSQ

[Trognitz]

still dirt

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rzKktoIKaT4

keep ur head up Marcy

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KnX6lsf9sdw

178 or 200+ ?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nKCeaqVCGmI

nice elbow, hows the throat Marcy ?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3CcEOH6W0A

[Trident]

From most feared to punching bag: Sandy McCarthy.

[flyin_finn]

Sami "Gentle Giant" Helenius - barely an middleweight who wanted to be heavyweight. Usually with not-so-impressevie results.

[TheUndertow40Six2]

Originally Posted by Bruise Bros 2426

Jody Shelley is another example of how guys kinda lose their fighting ability as they get older. Shelley can still throw, but he's not as effective as he was earlier in his career.

Bingo. In all my time watching him in Teal, the only fight I remember him actually winning was against Colton Orr. We traded him the next day.

[Gene Parmesan]

Originally Posted by TheUndertow40Six2

Bingo. In all my time watching him in Teal, the only fight I remember him actually winning was against Colton Orr. We traded him the next day.

He lost more than he won. He would do great against Brashear, Orr and Godard and Parros but drop the ball against Ivanans.