Start/Sit week #6

[BGDDYKWL]

Originally Posted by DEVILS ALL THE WAY

Tebow? I rather cross my fingers on Freeman... and Williams

Haha, I see we have another doubter (my friends all doubt me on this one as well). Granted he's a little more valuable in our league cause we get 4 points for passing TDs and 6 for rushing/receiving, but Tebow will be a top 5 fantasy QB from here on out. Otherwise I'll come back and delete this.

[Scotianhab]

Roethlisberger vs Jacksonvlle or Grossman vs Philly?

Manningham vs Bills or Meachem vs Tampa?

I'm leaning towards Manningham as I have Jimmy Graham as a TE for NO and will take Receptions from Meachem.

[Hot Carlson]

Originally Posted by BGDDYKWL

Haha, I see we have another doubter (my friends all doubt me on this one as well). Granted he's a little more valuable in our league cause we get 4 points for passing TDs and 6 for rushing/receiving, but Tebow will be a top 5 fantasy QB from here on out. Otherwise I'll come back and delete this.

I think Tebow could provide some short-term value, but over the long haul I'm not so sure. Once defensive coordinators start to draw up gameplans specifically designed to stop Tebow, the party could be over. I know, I know, he was the top QB the last 3 weeks last season, but Denver closed OAK/HOU/SD and last year only one of those resembled an actual NFL defense. I love the kid's heart and I love his drive but I think he's a year or two away from being a reliable fantasy QB.

Then again, I said the same thing about Cam Newton.

[Hot Carlson]

Originally Posted by Scotianhab

Roethlisberger vs Jacksonvlle or Grossman vs Philly?

Manningham vs Bills or Meachem vs Tampa?

I'm leaning towards Manningham as I have Jimmy Graham as a TE for NO and will take Receptions from Meachem.

Big Ben, easily.

Manningham, even though Victor Cruz is poaching a lot of his touches.

[DEVILS ALL THE WAY]

Landed Williams for 28$... nice. I changed my bid at the last minute and took Carlson's advice. Williams will probably be my 3rd/4th WR when all my guys will be healthy. Adding solid players threw the waiver wire is what can make or brake your season. Injuries happen way too often and guys you taught would do well, aren't. At the end of the day I was like "Having a good bench, especially in the bye weeks, is something I want but if I miss out... oh well, it's not the end of the world since I already have solid options.

Good advice. Now I have my dream guy on the bench starting in bye weeks.

I'm still uncertain about Mendenhall over Starks. The Steelers are playing Jacksonville and he'll be the starter but once they go up big, they'll probably take him out for Redman. Starks is facing the Rams and they are dead last against the run and when Rodgers starts torching them, they'll run it all day long IMO. And Grant can come in a screw everything up as well.

Mendenhall or Starks?

[Hollywood Couturier]

Witten or Davis?

[Hizaki]

Some last minute decisions...

RB #1: Gore
RB #2: BJGE, Ridley, or K. Hunter?

FLEX: Pettigrew or James Jones?
WR#1: Wayne
WR#1: J. Nelson


Leaning towards: Gore, Ridley, J. Jones, Wayne, J. Nelson...my QB is Rodgers so I'm just reaching for TD's with this...

Originally Posted by Hollywood Couturier

Witten or Davis?

I'd go Witten against the Pats. I own V. Davis, but I never trust him with Alex Smith at the helm...

[DEVILS ALL THE WAY]

Originally Posted by Hollywood Couturier

Witten or Davis?

Witten, hands down.

[Big Poppa Puck]

With Addai out, do I stick with Felix Jones or start Carter?

[Hizaki]

Originally Posted by DEVILS ALL THE WAY

Mendenhall or Starks?

I'd go with Mendenhall despite his performance so far...just a feeling. And he should get the bulk of the carries and not split at least...

Originally Posted by iRep TheWingedWheel

With Addai out, do I stick with Felix Jones or start Carter?

Felix Jones.

[DEVILS ALL THE WAY]

Originally Posted by Hizaki

I'd go with Mendenhall despite his performance so far...just a feeling. And he should get the bulk of the carries and not split at least...

I'm going with Starks for a couple of reasons.

1) The Rams are brutal against the run.
2) The Packers will take the lead and run the ball... alot.
3) With Jennings being 50/50, we'll see a heavy dose of Starks/Grant
4) The Jaguars are very solid against the run
5) Mendenhall is coming off a important injury and when his team will take the lead... they'll go with Redman IMO.

Now my question is for my WR3... Meachem or H. Ward?