Both offensive guys who play tough and are questionable defensively.... why is one better fit?
Because I think it is easier to impeach Egan's defensive game than it is Corbeau's. I don't think either was particularly good defensively, though, you're right there. I don't get why MadAr didn't just try to get a guy similar to Bill White to play next to Stapleton. There are approximately 47,000 of those defensemen in the ATD.