Girardi, easily. I hate Phaneuf, he is extremely overrated and a big coward to boot.
Coward? He fights when he should fight and hits when he should hits. I don't think I've seen a very dirty play by him other than that one on Kassian.
Anyways.. tough to call. Different players. Also Girardi is on one of the best teams in the league so that kinda sways people opinions. I'm sure if Phaneuf was on NY he would be +30 and be regarded as one of the best Dmen in the league.