The Trade Proposal Thread ‎2012 2.0

[MTL-rules]

Originally Posted by noahhabib

Would you guys trade Leblanc and Emelin for Scott Hartnell?

No, neither would Philly.

[loudi94]

Originally Posted by Analyzer

We all got our soft spots for some players, but he's a bottom 6 agitator. Could become more, but it's not likely.

What about trading Habs 2nd, 33rd overall (I'm not aware of any compensatory picks) + habs 3rd for a late first (27thish) to grab Wilson, or would it be better to target Frk if still available because his potential is (or from what I've read) fairly high ?

Never trust a guy with no vowels in his name.

[Captain Smurf]

Originally Posted by noahhabib

Would you guys trade Leblanc and Emelin for Scott Hartnell?

Yes, but Philly would laugh at that offer.

[Monctonscout]

Originally Posted by noahhabib

Would you guys trade Leblanc and Emelin for Scott Hartnell?

Isn't Hartnell a UFA in 1 year? That alone makes it a bad trade.

Plus, Hartnell is not really the type of player we are missing and his value is about as high as it can go coming off a career year.

[onemorecup]

A few hab buddies and I were chatting about the offseason moves to improve

one suggested we trade our top pick , if we dont win the lottery

to Colorado for Matt Duchene

very interesting move , 21 years old and easily our best center we have had in a decade

would you pull the trigger if the deal is on the table ?

[Teamwork]

I probably would, unless we win the lottery..

[FiveForDrawingBlood]

Originally Posted by onemorecup

A few hab buddies and I were chatting about the offseason moves to improve

one suggested we trade our top pick , if we dont win the lottery

to Colorado for Matt Duchene

very interesting move , 21 years old and easily our best center we have had in a decade

would you pull the trigger if the deal is on the table ?

No, Duchesne has had a real bad season. Question his hockey sense. Pick may be a homerun....should be no worse than Duchesne even if goes wrong

[charlie]

Meh.....looks like Duchene is going to have a career full of injuries.
I pass.

[habitue*]

Originally Posted by onemorecup

A few hab buddies and I were chatting about the offseason moves to improve

one suggested we trade our top pick , if we dont win the lottery

to Colorado for Matt Duchene

very interesting move , 21 years old and easily our best center we have had in a decade

would you pull the trigger if the deal is on the table ?

Duchesne or Taylor Hall would be my targets... Huberdeau, Etem or Coyle would also be interesting.

[LeMAD]

Yuck.

[JGRB]

Originally Posted by habitue

Duchesne or Taylor Hall would be my targets... Huberdeau, Etem or Coyle would also be interesting.

For some reason, I can't help but shake the feeling the Habs are going to be going after Huberdeau very hard with this pick. Whether or not Tallon bites is a completely different question... I am convinced the Habs are going to try and acquire him.

[Captain Saku]

Neither habs or colorado pulls the trigger.

Colorado still hopes he will bounce back, dont forget how close he and tavares were last 2 years. While from habs perspective it's too risky.

[donghabs98]

Originally Posted by Captain Saku

Neither habs or colorado pulls the trigger.

Colorado still hopes he will bounce back, dont forget how close he and tavares were last 2 years. While from habs perspective it's too risky.

ya
even if he get him knowing how injuries happen in montreal

duchene would be hurt somehow entering the taxi to take him to the bell centre

[uiCk]

he's good, but better then Yakupov will be? dunno

[Player 61]

Naw! I'd rather take the chances with the pick. These quick fix solutions never seem to work.

[Ohashi_Jouzu]

Good kid, Duchene. But do not want. Would much rather take the chance on the pick.

[Saopolo123]

Montreal trades Brian Gionta and yannick weber to Min for Kyle Brodziak and their 2nd round pick 2012.

Montreal trades Lars Eller, Rafael Diaz, Aaron Palushaj, First round pick 2013 to Colombus for Rick Nash and 2nd round pick 2013.

Montreal sing defencman Shane O'brien.
Montreal sing travis Moen.
Montreal sing Brad Staubitz.
Kaberle retires for his new children.

Montreal got - three 2nd round pick in 2012 draft
- four 2nd round pick 2013 draft

Next year :

Pacc - D.D - Nash
Gallagher - Plekanec - Cole (Cole will have an impact on Gall ! Book it)
Bourque - Brodziak - Geoffrion
Moen - White - Staubitz
Darche


Subban - Gorges
Markov - Emelin
St Denis - O'Brien

Price
Budaj

[Ivan13]

Originally Posted by Ohashi_Jouzu

Good kid, Duchene. But do not want. Would much rather take the chance on the pick.

Yes because Habs pick is a sure fire home run. I guess proven NHL talent with loads of potential is worth less than a prospect who didn't play a minute of NHL hockey.

And to those questioning his health in the long run, he had two freak accidents.

There's no way Avs trade him for Habs 1st round pick.

[NoahH57]

Would you guys do the following trade?

To Montreal
Alex Burmistrov
Mark Schiefele
Ivan Telegin
3rd round pick

To Winnipeg
Subban
Plekanec

[Roke]

Originally Posted by noahhabib

Would you guys do the following trade?

To Montreal
Alex Burmistrov
Mark Schiefele
Ivan Telegin
3rd round pick

To Winnipeg
Subban
Plekanec

Why would Montreal give up the best two players in the trade (and their most important 2 if they want to win)?

[danyhabsfan]

Originally Posted by Saopolo123

Montreal trades Brian Gionta and yannick weber to Min for Kyle Brodziak and their 2nd round pick 2012.

Montreal trades Lars Eller, Rafael Diaz, Aaron Palushaj, First round pick 2013 to Colombus for Rick Nash and 2nd round pick 2013.

Montreal sing defencman Shane O'brien.
Montreal sing travis Moen.
Montreal sing Brad Staubitz.
Kaberle retires for his new children.

Montreal got - three 2nd round pick in 2012 draft
- four 2nd round pick 2013 draft

Next year :

Pacc - D.D - Nash
Gallagher - Plekanec - Cole (Cole will have an impact on Gall ! Book it)
Bourque - Brodziak - Geoffrion
Moen - White - Staubitz
Darche


Subban - Gorges
Markov - Emelin
St Denis - O'Brien

Price
Budaj

Brodziak just sign an extension.
Columbus wouldnt touch that deal. AINEC

Montreal sing?
Where's Kaberle?

[NoahH57]

Niederieter, De Haan, 2nd round pick (NYI) for Subban?

[overlords]

Originally Posted by noahhabib

Would you guys do the following trade?

To Montreal
Alex Burmistrov
Mark Schiefele
Ivan Telegin
3rd round pick

To Winnipeg
Subban
Plekanec

No way.

[Analyzer]

Originally Posted by Saopolo123

Montreal trades Brian Gionta and yannick weber to Min for Kyle Brodziak and their 2nd round pick 2012.

Montreal trades Lars Eller, Rafael Diaz, Aaron Palushaj, First round pick 2013 to Colombus for Rick Nash and 2nd round pick 2013.

Montreal sing defencman Shane O'brien.
Montreal sing travis Moen.
Montreal sing Brad Staubitz.
Kaberle retires for his new children.

Montreal got - three 2nd round pick in 2012 draft
- four 2nd round pick 2013 draft

Next year :

Pacc - D.D - Nash
Gallagher - Plekanec - Cole (Cole will have an impact on Gall ! Book it)
Bourque - Brodziak - Geoffrion
Moen - White - Staubitz
Darche


Subban - Gorges
Markov - Emelin
St Denis - O'Brien

Price
Budaj

Originally Posted by noahhabib

Would you guys do the following trade?

To Montreal
Alex Burmistrov
Mark Schiefele
Ivan Telegin
3rd round pick

To Winnipeg
Subban
Plekanec

Do either of you live in the real world ?

Originally Posted by noahhabib

Niederieter, De Haan, 2nd round pick (NYI) for Subban?

Pass.

[goldglove]

To Detroit:

Andrei Markov
Yannick Weber
Aaron Palaushaj

To Montreal:

Johan Franzen
Xavier Ouellet
Trevor Parkes