Which Defencemen?

[Tyler Durden]

So I am thinking of trading either Green/Kaberle/Garrison and Hudler for Parenteau and either:

Wideman
Doughty
White
Carle
Timonen
Burns

From this list who is the best overall defencemen? H2H league we count G A PTS PPP +/- SOG HITS PIM

[Cappy]

Doughty Burns Timonen Wides White Carle

good luck with the other owner accepting hudler+green/kaberle/garrison for PA+any of those guys at the top...

[Tyler Durden]

From green/kaberle/garrison who should I offer?

[Cappy]

Originally Posted by Tyler Durden

From green/kaberle/garrison who should I offer?

get rid of kaberle, even if you can't find someone to trade him to just drop him and pick someone else up. then garrison then green last.

[Tyler Durden]

LOL I dont understand why everyone is hating on Kaberle he puts up points especially on the PP the only fault I see in him is +/- and he has to shoot the puck more.

[Cappy]

Originally Posted by Tyler Durden

LOL I dont understand why everyone is hating on Kaberle

-he plays softer than a piece of wet toilet tissue
-he holds his blueline like a revolving door
-he is too stupid to learn defensive systems beyond straight man to man(which again he is too soft to play effectively)
-he is unselfish with the puck to a fault(because he is so afraid of getting hit he immediately relieves himself of that burden)
-the pp is supposedly a strength of his yet the last time one of his teams ranked above league average on the pp was 07-08 leafs when they cashed in on 17.78% and the league average was 17.75%(really pulling away from the pack)
-did i mention that he plays soft?

i dislike his game intensely for reasons that don't affect fantasy hockey, so take my advice on him with a grain of salt i guess

[barabr10]

I think if you want parenteau and a defencemen like doughty or burns you need to offer green for the owner to consider your trade offer