This would be interesting to read, like in Consumer Reports when they grade the different parts of the car. But it would take a long time to do this, and milliseconds for the next poster to rip it apart.
I do however think that this is exactly what professional scouts and video game programmers have to do in order to give their ratings a semblance of science.
Nice post Shareefruck. I like that you included hockey sense. Such an under-appreciated attribute in players yet probably the most important of all. Personally I think you're underrating Weise a little here as I do think he's shown some smarts out there - not blatantly obvious but it's there.
In the immortal words of Cory Schneider: A little bit of Jannik Hansen?
Hockey sense: Very good
Puck control: Decent
Wrist shot: Mediocre
Slap shot: Decent
Forechecking: Very good
Compete level: Very good