I'm sorry but in what world is Jamie Moyer an HOF'er? Pitching until you're 100, while impressive doesn't get you in if the rest of your stats are extremely mediocre.
Schilling is a tough one. While he was never in the super elite, he was really good for a long time and his W-L record probably doesn't do him justice. I'm inclined to say no, but I wouldn't be horribly upset if he got in.
Mike 'Moose' Mussina
Last edited by GIN ANTONIC: 03-17-2012 at 11:31 AM.
I'm sorry but in what world is Jamie Moyer an HOF'er? Pitching until you're 100, while impressive doesn't get you in if the rest of your stats are extremely mediocre.
Schilling is a tough one. While he was never in the super elite, he was really good for a long time and his W-L record probably doesn't do him justice. I'm inclined to say no, but I wouldn't be upset if he got in.
Like Rollins, he had a good shot but I don't see it happening now. They can both get it on track but they'd need to turn back the clock. Utley has a better shot I'll say.
Felix Hernandez
Like Rollins, he had a good shot but I don't see it happening now. They can both get it on track but they'd need to turn back the clock. Utley has a better shot I'll say.
Felix Hernandez
Impossible to say now. Yes if he continues to roll and if he gets on a better team, because like it or not wins factor in. Not saying they necessarily should, but we all know they do.
This one's tough for me, but I'm leaning towards yes. He was overshadowed by the greatest lead-off hitter of all-time but he was excellent in his own right.
On the fence leaning towards the no side. More of a journeyman than anything towards the latter part of his career, but a .299 career BA and in the Top 20 in stolen bases do stick out.
Continuing with "Indians of the 90's", Omar Vizquel.
On the fence leaning towards the no side. More of a journeyman than anything towards the latter part of his career, but a .299 career BA and in the Top 20 in stolen bases do stick out.
Continuing with "Indians of the 90's", Omar Vizquel.
He's in my HOF. He's got 11 gold gloves but he should have twice as many. The sickest fielder I've ever seen. I'd say his offense isn't bad enough to keep him out. He had some pretty solid seasons at the plate.
EDGAR MARTINEZ
He's in my HOF. He's got 11 gold gloves but he should have twice as many. The sickest fielder I've ever seen. I'd say his offense isn't bad enough to keep him out. He had some pretty solid seasons at the plate.
EDGAR MARTINEZ
I'd put him in but I don't think the voters will.
"The Crime Dog" Fred McGriff.
On Kenny Lofton; he was one of my favorite players growing up. He may hang on the ballot a few years but I don't think he'll ever get in. I think the journeyman thing will be a strike against him too. Hall of Very Good.
On Kenny Lofton; he was one of my favorite players growing up. He may hang on the ballot a few years but I don't think he'll ever get in. I think the journeyman thing will be a strike against him too. Hall of Very Good.
Super consistent. 7 more HR and it boosts his odds big time. Although it really shouldn't. I'm right on the fence, but leaning towards no. Wouldn't be upset if he got it though.
Todd Helton
Another on the fence. Not too impressive offensively especially for playing in Colorado all his career outside of RBI's at this point, (Has more than Clemente, Gwynn, Dale Murphy, and Puckett while on pace to eclipse Santo, Fisk, and Rose this season) but I can also see him getting in as the first Rockie just so they have representation kind of like the logic of inducting Andre Dawson as an Expo.
