Claude Giroux vs Eric Staal

[Reparlana]

Who do you take?

[Machinehead]

Giroux AINEC

[Trance Kuja]

Giroux until after the All-Star break.

[Laino]

Eric Staal, if he was on the Flyers he would have 130+ points. Giroux on Carolina only puts up 40-something

[Pronounced Anders]

Giroux... really not close.

[Machinehead]

Originally Posted by Laino

Eric Staal, if he was on the Flyers he would have 130+ points. Giroux on Carolina only puts up 40-something

Yeah you're right, clearly Giroux is lifted by the superstar skills of Scott Hartnell and a fresh young Jaromir Jagr.

[JVR21]

Giroux over Staal ceteris paribus.

Giroux at $3.75M vs. Staal at $8.25? Not even comparable.

[Gritzky98]

Giroux AINEC

You can get 2 Girouxs for the price of 1 Staal

[Novak Djokovic]

Giroux's a better player definitely, but for some reason, I'd rather have Staal on the Sens. Don't know why.

[Kresnik]

Giroux, a better player basically

[Brooklanders*]

Originally Posted by Gritzky98

Giroux AINEC

You can get 2 Girouxs for the price of 1 Staal

Maybe but there are 3 other Staals

[211*]

Originally Posted by Laino

Eric Staal, if he was on the Flyers he would have 130+ points. Giroux on Carolina only puts up 40-something

easily the most retarded post i have ever read, anywhere

[Luigi Lemieux]

Giroux has passed him. Staal didn't even start playing until the Canes were safely out of the playoffs.

[2 12 oz Drinks]

If this is because what BCC posted, you do realize that whole thread was intended as a joke. Read some more of his posts and you'll understand

[I Hate Chris Butler]

The Superiority Complex is strong in this one.

[Reparlana]

Way to over think life^^, I don't see why this isn't a reasonable poll..

I'm shaking in my boots

Career = Staal but Giroux in his break out year. I think its a fair poll. God knows we could bump this next year and it could be Giroux who??

[2 12 oz Drinks]

Originally Posted by Reparlana

Way to over think life^^, I don't see why this isn't a reasonable poll..

A career point per game player or this seasons most overrated player

Delete

[2 12 oz Drinks]

I still say Giroux but it's not as far as people think. It's not like we're comparing Giroux and Jokinen or some other Canes center. But OP does have a point, this is his first 70 point season. However, I highly doubt it is his last. Is he a better player right now? Certainly. Is he is better player altogether? Time will tell

[billybudd]

I said Giroux, but only because of money. If they made the same thing, I'm taking Staal.

[Sureves]

Said Staal at beginning of the year and was fairly confident (read: arrogant) in my view that it would stay that way at the end of the year.

I was wrong: it's Giroux.

[MrFunnyWobbl]

Originally Posted by 211

easily the most retarded post i have ever read, anywhere

This man wins.

[1865]

Originally Posted by 2 12 oz Drinks

I still say Giroux but it's not as far as people think. It's not like we're comparing Giroux and Jokinen or some other Canes center. But OP does have a point, this is his first 70 point season. However, I highly doubt it is his last. Is he a better player right now? Certainly. Is he is better player altogether? Time will tell

No it's not. Giroux has something like 165 points in his last 2 seasons, and that's not including the play-offs.

[Endersoldier]

Clode

[GIN ANTONIC]

Staal is having a top 5 season all-time in Claude Giroux adjusted points. Yeah, you read that correct. ALL-TIME.

I don't even see how this is should be remotely close.

[Habs 4 Life]

Close but right now i'd take Giroux