Worst Young Goalie Tandem

[Stephen]

What's the worst young goalie tandem in Leafs history?

Allan Bester and Ken Wregget of the mid to late 1980s
Peter Ing and Jeff Reese of the early 1990s
James Reimer and Jonas Gustavsson of the 2010s

[hotpaws]

Originally Posted by Stephen

What's the worst young goalie tandem in Leafs history?

Allan Bester and Ken Wregget of the mid to late 1980s
Peter Ing and Jeff Reese of the early 1990s
James Reimer and Jonas Gustavsson of the 2010s

I'll go Ing and Reese , i don't think it can ge any worse than that .

[p.l.f.]

toskala and....

[Longshot]

Originally Posted by p.l.f.

toskala and....

Exactly.

I still find it hard to believe that the last three General Manager of the Maple Leafs believed Toskala could be a starting goalie in the NHL.

[forsberg]

Toskala and Raycroft were good prior coming to the Leafs

[Longshot]

Originally Posted by forsberg

Toskala and Raycroft were good prior coming to the Leafs

Raycroft was rookie of the year. But his second year was worse than the season Reimer is having. Toskala was a back up with San Jose and had never been a number one goalie in the NHL.

[pooleboy]

Remember that thread "isn't it great we have two #1 goalies now" that was the good old days.

[Eli]

Originally Posted by pooleboy

Remember that thread "isn't it great we have two #1 goalies now" that was the good old days.

That was such a jinx thread. Both our goalies started sucking after that. :

[Pinchy]

This isn't a tandem, it's a trio.

Reimer, Gustavson and Rynass.

Our problems are solved!

[Eb]

I love how the OP says "of the 2010's" when in fact this is the only season our goaltending has been below par with these two.

[Stephen]

Originally Posted by Eb

I love how the OP says "of the 2010's" when in fact this is the only season our goaltending has been below par with these two.

Reese and Ing were only around for a couple of years too, and we're only a couple of years into the 2010s... And Gustavsson has been terrible every year he's been here and Reimer has been terrible for half his career...

[BillyD]

how about jiri crha + vincent tremblay

[GardinerExpress]

heres a good question, would you rather have glen healys goaltending or his commentary

[Stephen]

Originally Posted by LukeSchennWalker

heres a good question, would you rather have glen healys goaltending or his commentary

Haha nice one.

Also, kind of funny that Craig Simpson told the Leafs not to draft him, and now he has to do play by play for them...

[SuperJayMann]

Yeah that was good.

I choose his goaltending, we never had to see or hear him on the bench.

[Gardiner]

good ol peter ing lmao

[MorriPage]

I never realized how spoiled I was from getting to watch Curtis Joseph and then Eddie Belfour between the pipes until I was fed a steady diet of Vesa Toskala, Andrew Raycroft and Jonas Gustavsson.

[Enhanced]

Originally Posted by MorriPage

I never realized how spoiled I was from getting to watch Curtis Joseph and then Eddie Belfour between the pipes until I was fed a steady diet of Vesa Toskala, Andrew Raycroft and Jonas Gustavsson.

Hell yeah. Back in those days when I was younger and a lot less knowledgeable, I thought goaltending was nothing too important. Potvin, Joseph and Belfour all came in and made it seem routine. I thought all NHL teams had average goalies while maybe a handful of teams had great ones (Roy, Brodeur, Hasek).

Nowadays, I can firmly say we have had bad goalies and would kill for something average. Never seen a team get destroyed by goaltending for so many years while trying so many different options.

[Vaive]

Originally Posted by Stephen

What's the worst young goalie tandem in Leafs history?

Allan Bester and Ken Wregget of the mid to late 1980s
Peter Ing and Jeff Reese of the early 1990s
James Reimer and Jonas Gustavsson of the 2010s

Technically it would be Mark LaForest/Jeff Reese as seen here: http://www.hockeydb.com/ihdb/stats/l...000381990.html

Although I liked LaForest....and I absolutely loved Ken Wregget. I was totally choked when we traded Wregget away to Philly......

Goalies I hated: Tellqvist, Kidd, Toskala, Raycroft, Ing, Puppa....

[Nasty Nazem]

Originally Posted by MorriPage

I never realized how spoiled I was from getting to watch Curtis Joseph and then Eddie Belfour between the pipes until I was fed a steady diet of Vesa Toskala, Andrew Raycroft and Jonas Gustavsson.

Unfortunately, I didn't get to watch either of those two so all I've seen are Raycroft, Toskala, Gus, Giguere, Reimer, Gerber and how sad is it that Gerber might have given us one of the better stretches of goaltending post-lockout?

What a terrible collection pile of garbage.

[thadd]

I can remember getting SO pissed off opening a pack of cards to get another Peter Ing or Jeff Reese card.

[thadd]

Originally Posted by Steams12

Technically it would be Mark LaForest/Jeff Reese as seen here: http://www.hockeydb.com/ihdb/stats/l...000381990.html

Although I liked LaForest....and I absolutely loved Ken Wregget. I was totally choked when we traded Wregget away to Philly......

Goalies I hated: Tellqvist, Kidd, Toskala, Raycroft, Ing, Puppa....

I don't understand what happened to Kidd. He was completely useless in the NHL.

[Giuseppe Sallo]

Man, we suck at drafting/trading for keepers. Bring back Ed Belfour.

[MeowLeafs]

Recently, it would be Toskala and a 41 year old Cujo.