Rank the top 10 PIM leaders as overall players.

[DickSmehlik]

3996 Dave 'Tiger' Williams (1974-1988)
3565 Dale Hunter (1980-1999)
3515 Tie Domi (1989-2006)
3381 Marty McSorley (1983-2000)
3300 Bob Probert (1985-2002)
3207 Rob Ray (1989-2004)
3149 Craig Berube (1986-2003)
3146 Tim Hunter (1981-1997)
3043 Chris Nilan (1979-1992)
2972 Rick Tocchet (1984-2002)

1. Tochet
2. Dale Hunter
3. McSorley
4. Williams
5. Probert
6. Domi
7. Nilan
8. Tim Hunter
9. Berube
10. Ray

[John Flyers Fan]

1. Tocchet
2. Hunter
3. Probert
4. McSorley
5. Nilan
6. Williams
7. Hunter
8. Domi
9. Berube
10. Ray

[GreatGonzo]

1. Tocchet
2. D. Hunter
3. McSorley
4. Probert
5. T. Hunter
6. Williams
7. Nilan
8. Ray
9. Domi
10. Berube

[Sens Rule]

1. Tocchet
2. Dale Hunter
3. Probert
4. McSorley
5. Nilan
6. Williams
7. Domi
8. Tim Hunter
9. Berube
10. Ray

Where would you place Chris Neil on this list? Above Domi?

[Ogie Goldthorpe]

1.Tocchet

2. D. Hunter

3. Probert
4. Williams
5. McSorley

6. T. Hunter
7. Nilan
8. Domi

9. Berube
10. Ray


Chris Neil ahead of Domi and Nilan... behind T. Hunter.

[seventieslord]

Tocchet
Hunter

McSorley (a good #4 defenseman for a while, NHL +/- leader)


Williams
Probert



Domi
Nilan


Hunter

Berube
Ray

edit: turns out I 100% agree with the OP!

edit again: 9 of these 10 players were active in the 89-90 season. Only Williams wasn't.

[DickSmehlik]

Originally Posted by DickSmehlik

3996 Dave 'Tiger' Williams (1974-1988)
3565 Dale Hunter (1980-1999)
3515 Tie Domi (1989-2006)
3381 Marty McSorley (1983-2000)
3300 Bob Probert (1985-2002)
3207 Rob Ray (1989-2004)
3149 Craig Berube (1986-2003)
3146 Tim Hunter (1981-1997)
3043 Chris Nilan (1979-1992)
2972 Rick Tocchet (1984-2002)

The next 5 make it more interesting. How would you rank the top 15?

2905 Pat Verbeek
2891 Chris Chelios
2792 Dave Manson
2785 Scott Stevens
2634 Donald Brashear

[John Flyers Fan]

Originally Posted by DickSmehlik

The next 5 make it more interesting. How would you rank the top 15?

2905 Pat Verbeek
2891 Chris Chelios
2792 Dave Manson
2785 Scott Stevens
2634 Donald Brashear

Chelios is 1
Stevens is 2

Verbeek is definitely behind Tocchet, close with Dale Hunter, I could see arguments for both.

Manson at his best was better than McSorely.

I would slot Brashear above Domi.

[billybudd]

[QUOTE=DickSmehlik;47239753]3996 Dave 'Tiger' Williams (1974-1988)
3565 Dale Hunter (1980-1999)
3515 Tie Domi (1989-2006)
3381 Marty McSorley (1983-2000)
3300 Bob Probert (1985-2002)
3207 Rob Ray (1989-2004)
3149 Craig Berube (1986-2003)
3146 Tim Hunter (1981-1997)
3043 Chris Nilan (1979-1992)
2972 Rick Tocchet (1984-2002)

1. Tocchet (first one's easy)
2. D Hunter
3. Williams
4. Probert
5. McSorely
6. Domi
7. Tim Hunter
8. Nilan
9. Ray
10. Berube (so is the last one)

[cursednumber6]

1.D Hunter
2.R Tocchet
3.Tiger Williams
4.Probert
5. Mcsorley
6. Nilan
7Domi
8.Tim Hunter
9. Berube
10 Ray.....Nine and Ten were eh...too close to call.

[tony d]

1) Tocchet
2) D.Hunter
3) McSorley
4) Williams
5) Probert
6) T.Hunter
7) Domi
8) Nilan
9) Berube
10) Ray

[seventieslord]

Originally Posted by DickSmehlik

The next 5 make it more interesting. How would you rank the top 15?

2905 Pat Verbeek
2891 Chris Chelios
2792 Dave Manson
2785 Scott Stevens
2634 Donald Brashear

The fact that you got just one answer tells me you made it a less interesting thread!

anyway:

Chelios

Stevens




Tocchet
Hunter
Verbeek

McSorley (a good #4 defenseman for a while, NHL +/- leader)


Williams
Probert

Manson

Domi
Nilan


Hunter

Brashear

Berube
Ray