He's the worst in game manager in baseball hands down. Young starting at 1st then Holland in relief of Darvish. What a joke.
He's not a great in-game manager by any stretch but he's far from the worst. You're basically saying that his team wins in spite of him, which just can't be the case on my nights given how many games this team has won over the past three years.
That's exactly what I'm saying. He's only good for his relationships with his players. Even that leads to bad managing. He rolled MY out there basically all season despite having the worst possible production from a DH/1B/3B. Kept throwing Nathan out there in non save situations. At one point he said he was never going to do it again. He then went on to do it multiple times within the next couple of weeks.
Forget which year it was in the World Series, but Esteban German made an appearance as a pinch hitter in a huge situation. Considering it was Esteban freaking German that didn't go so well.
There's also situations I named from tonight, and that's really just getting started.