rank the goalies going forward

[tape to tape]

smith
brodeur
quick
lundqust

[Mystlyfe]

Quick
Lundqvist
Smith
Brodeur

[Machinehead]

Anyone who doesn't have Brodeur last needs to send us a post card from 2003.

[tape to tape]

Originally Posted by Machinehead

Anyone who doesn't have Brodeur last needs to send us a post card from 2003.

what the hill does this mean

[Machinehead]

Originally Posted by tape to tape

what the hill does this mean

He WAS the best, key word being was. Right now he's the worst of the four AINEC.

[5RingsAndABeer]

Originally Posted by tape to tape

what the hill does this mean

he is over it

[tape to tape]

Originally Posted by Machinehead

He WAS the best, key word being was. Right now he's the worst of the four AINEC.

ok

of the 4 he has a gold medal and a few stanley cup rings

but whatever

[njdevscup30]

Smith
Quick
Lundy
Marty

[MartysBackup]

Originally Posted by Machinehead

He WAS the best, key word being was. Right now he's the worst of the four AINEC.

As a Devils fan, I have to agree. That said, I have to say my list is:

1) Lundqvist's pads
2) Quick
3) Smith
4) Lundqvist
5) Brodeur

[charlie460]

Lundqvist
Quick
Smith
Marty

[Machinehead]

Originally Posted by tape to tape

ok

of the 4 he has a gold medal and a few stanley cup rings

but whatever

Yeah, from 2003, like I said. Get working on that postcard.

[wKetch22]

Originally Posted by tape to tape

what the hill does this mean

is that you Bryz?

"i saw man today in park,he dressed in women clothes and high hills."

[Machinehead]

Originally Posted by MartysBackup

As a Devils fan, I have to agree. That said, I have to say my list is:

1) Lundqvist's pads
2) Quick
3) Smith
4) Lundqvist
5) Brodeur

Well I can agree with this. As long as we're being honest Lundqvist's glove hand gives me fits.

[wKetch22]

Originally Posted by tape to tape

what the hill does this mean

Originally Posted by MartysBackup

As a Devils fan, I have to agree. That said, I have to say my list is:

1) Lundqvist's pads
2) Quick
3) Smith
4) Lundqvist
5) Brodeur

lmao

so true

[tape to tape]

Originally Posted by Machinehead

Yeah, from 2003, like I said. Get working on that postcard.

so true, Marty is a product of system, and without Daneyko, Stevens, and Niedemeirer he will not succeed...

[AJRAYMOND]

Quick
Lundqvist
Smith
v
v
v
v

Brodeur
Top 3 are in a class all their own.

[Machinehead]

Originally Posted by tape to tape

so true, Marty is a product of system, and without Daneyko, Stevens, and Niedemeirer he will not succeed...

I never said that. But Marty is old and not quite what he was back then. Even Devils fans will tell you that.

[MartysBackup]

Originally Posted by Machinehead

I never said that. But Marty is old and not quite what he was back then. Even Devils fans will tell you that.

Puck-stopping wise, yes. But his stickhandling has been as good as its ever been. Ask Flyers fans how much of an effect that's had.

[TheUnseenHand]

Lundquist/Quick
Smith
Brodeur

Marty isn't anywhere near what he used to be. That said, there is one area where he trumps the other 3 guys clearly (even Smith): Stickhandling. Yes, he has made a couple gaffs, but for the most part his stickhandling gave the Panthers and especially the Flyers absolute fits.

[Carl Hagelins Flow]

Originally Posted by MartysBackup

As a Devils fan, I have to agree. That said, I have to say my list is:

1) Lundqvist's pads
2) Quick
3) Smith
4) Lundqvist
5) Brodeur

Well since we're playing this game:

As a Rangers fan, I have to agree. That said, I have to say my list is:

1) Lundqvist's pads
2) Quick's pads
3) Smith's stick
4) Brodeur's flopping and diving
5) Quick
6) Lundqvist
7) Smith
8) Brodeur
9) Lundqvist's glove

[Machinehead]

Originally Posted by MartysBackup

Puck-stopping wise, yes. But his stickhandling has been as good as its ever been. Ask Flyers fans how much of an effect that's had.

Originally Posted by TheUnseenHand

Lundquist/Quick
Smith
Brodeur

Marty isn't anywhere near what he used to be. That said, there is one area where he trumps the other 3 guys clearly (even Smith): Stickhandling. Yes, he has made a couple gaffs, but for the most part his stickhandling gave the Panthers and especially the Flyers absolute fits.

No question, what Marty does outside the crease is still a great weapon, whereas "Stay in the net Hank!" is probably in the top 5 of things I shout during the game, so he wins there.

[Machinehead]

Originally Posted by Carl Hagelins Flow

Well since we're playing this game:

As a Rangers fan, I have to agree. That said, I have to say my list is:

1) Lundqvist's pads
2) Quick's pads
3) Smith's stick
4) Brodeur's flopping and diving
5) Quick
6) Lundqvist
7) Smith
8) Brodeur
9) Lundqvist's glove

Surely we can't be forgetting Lundqvist's head

[AJBergy86]

Lundqvist
Quick
Smith
Brodeur

[MartysBackup]

Originally Posted by Carl Hagelins Flow

Well since we're playing this game:

As a Rangers fan, I have to agree. That said, I have to say my list is:

1) Lundqvist's pads
2) Quick's pads
3) Smith's stick
4) Brodeur's flopping and diving
5) Quick
6) Lundqvist
7) Smith
8) Brodeur
9) Lundqvist's glove

That's about as comprehensive and perfect a list as I could have possibly imagined. Well done!

[KingWantsCup]

1.) Vezina Winner
2.) Quick

3.) Smith


4.) Brodeur