Proposal: Edm-Tor

[The Pouzar]

Edmonton trades Hall and Gagner for Gardiner, Colbourne and 5th Overall.

[HockeyFanSince86]

No.........

[DuckEatinShark]

Be prepared to be flamed (and deservedly so) by Oilers fans.

Doubt that gets you Hall alone.

[usernam*]

This is actually awful...

[Whoyawit*]

I'm going to assume you're a 12 year old.
If not, maybe you should consider closing your account.
Close this junk proposal mods - thank you.

[victor]

Yuck. Wouldn't trade Hall for that.

[longchange]

can't believe i'm out of popcorn...

[JKsilverstick*]

No from the Leafs. Hall and Gagner aren't what we need.

[Central Scrutinizer]

Originally Posted by HockeyFanSince86

No.........

Are you an oilers fan?

[norton17]

I'm a Leafs fan
I'm a huge Taylor Hall fan


I don't think I'd do this as a Leafs fan, Hall is better than the 5th overall...but Gardiner is WAY better, with WAY more potential than Gagner.

We have Connolly and Lombardi who are like Gagber and we cant give them away!

[Johnny Bravo]

Originally Posted by JKsilverstick

No from the Leafs. Hall and Gagner aren't what we need.

LOL, Most people would give their left nut for Hall. Not one player on the leafs lives up to Hall.

[The Pouzar]

As a modified proposal how does Hall for Gardiner and 5th overall work?

[Johnny Bravo]

Originally Posted by The Pouzar

As a modified proposal how does Hall for Gardiner and 5th overall work?

Still horrible.

[Neatman]

Originally Posted by norton17

I'm a Leafs fan
I'm a huge Taylor Hall fan


I don't think I'd do this as a Leafs fan, Hall is better than the 5th overall...but Gardiner is WAY better, with WAY more potential than Gagner.

We have Connolly and Lombardi who are like Gagber and we cant give them away!

Hall is better than the 5th overall? How generous of you?

To be fair, it is a big package coming from Toronto, I just have absolutely no interest in shipping Taylor Hall out. Absolutely none. People (not necessarily Oiler fans) that watch Hall play know he changes the dynamic of the Oiler offence COMPLETELY when he's on the ice.

People can talk about him being "injury prone", but Im all for holding onto him and seeing what happens. His ceiling is far beyond what many on this site peg him at imo.

[Johnny Bravo]

Originally Posted by Johnny Bravo

Still horrible.

We aren't trading our future captain /thread.

[The Pouzar]

Originally Posted by Johnny Bravo

We aren't trading our future captain /thread.

Except that I've heard rumours that Hall wants to play in Toronto.

[dan1el]

Originally Posted by Johnny Bravo

LOL, Most people would give their left nut for Hall. Not one player on the leafs lives up to Hall.

Sens fan here who would be shocked if Hall is ever as good as Kessel. 37 goal, 82-pointers aren't that common and nothing I've seen from has shown he'll be that good.

[SIDGENO8771]

Originally Posted by The Pouzar

Edmonton trades Hall and Gagner for Gardiner, Colbourne and 5th Overall.

No way we give Gardiner and the 5th overall

Keep your future captain Send us Eberle +

[Johnny Bravo]

Originally Posted by The Pouzar

Except that I've heard rumours that Hall wants to play in Toronto.

I guess all star players want to play in toronto

[Alexander Baigle]

As a Toronto fan I wouldn't want to do this trade. It's not that I don't like the value on our end, and it's not that Hall is a bad player (he isn't.) but he's not the piece we're looking for in Toronto.

[Mystifo]

Originally Posted by Johnny Bravo

LOL, Most people would give their left nut for Hall. Not one player on the leafs lives up to Hall.

Funny I could of swore Kessel has outscored Hall?

[Homesick]

Originally Posted by SIDGENO8771

No way we give Gardiner and the 5th overall

Keep your future captain Send us Eberle +

We'll send you Eberle's + size deuce that he drops when Hall punks him by saying he's been traded to Toronto

[kamosko]

I wouldn't trade gardiner+5th overall for Hall

I don't seem Edmonton trading Hall for that either

[Neatman]

Originally Posted by dan1el

Sens fan here who would be shocked if Hall is ever as good as Kessel. 37 goal, 82-pointers aren't that common and nothing I've seen from has shown he'll be that good.

If you havent seen anything from Hall that shows "he'll be that good", then you really havent seen the kid play much. He's had a couple injury plagued seasons, and already in his second season he scored at a 71pt 36g pace. On the second worst team in the league (also below average in scoring).

That's ignoring that he is much more physical than Kessel, and i would also speculate Hall is the better leader.

[franfrey*]

Originally Posted by dan1el

Sens fan here who would be shocked if Hall is ever as good as Kessel. 37 goal, 82-pointers aren't that common and nothing I've seen from has shown he'll be that good.

You must have only seen his bad games then... He's definitely the Oilers' most dominant, dynamic and important forward. Future captain too.