Value of: Brent Seabrook to Phi

[UniverStalinGraduate*]

Originally Posted by Blackhawkswincup

I am gonna have to disagree with Sarava here ,, He wouldn't cost Giroux

Coburn + Couturier + 1st is much more reasonable

Hawks aren't trading our 2nd best dman without getting a dman back and a guy who we can slot in as #2 C

That's such a bad trade for the Hawks.

Couturier might be a number 2 center in a few years but he's still so young and like others have said the Hawks are trying to win the cup.

Coburn is an average d-man, probably a number 4 on a good team.

The guy who said Giroux is right, it'd never happen but if Philadelphia was going to get Seabrook from the Hawks they'd have to give Giroux.

[WarriorofTime]

Originally Posted by oilerbear

Sean couturier faced the other teams best in the most difficult tough comp situation. he was 20 P better than the expected average. the average player in this role is -14 to -18 per season.

the kid was top 20 for PK in his position.

Quite honestly. he was the best defensive player in the league last year as a rookie.
backes and bergeron were top 10.
Datsyuk started in the offensive zone 55% of the time. Defensive? that is a ..... joke!

Hawks already have a third line center, his name is Dave Bolland. No point in getting a player who right now is another one for a big Dman like Seabrook.