Future Oiler NHL Prospects Number #4

[oilersfan11]

Number 1 Prospect Nail Yakupov





Number 2 Prospect Oscar Klefbom





Number 3 Prospect Martin Marincin

[402]

I'm not sure I gotta go with gernat

[SephF]

I'd say Pitlick then Gernat

[OilDrop37]

Not sure who it is, but it needs to be Bunz or Roy

[Nailor Hopberle]

Had to go with Reider, 40+ goals this last year is pretty incredible.

[Koto]

went with gernat, but its a tossup with pitlick imo

[ManByng]

gotta go with Bunz, especially given we didn't draft a goalie this time around....leaves us with Dubnyk, Bunz, Roy and a bunch of question marks for goalie prospects. and look at Bunz's record the last 3 years in Medicine Hat and the fact he was WHL goalie of the year this year.

[Mr Forever]

Why aren't Lander or Hartikianen on this

[I am the Liquor]

Musil. Easily.

How on earth did Marincin get in ahead of him?

[oilersfan11]

Originally Posted by Mr Forever

Why aren't Lander or Hartikianen on this

They have played too many games?

[ManByng]

@ I Am The Liquor....because Musil is seen as a bottom pairing d-man, whereas it is hoped Marincin will be a top 4.

[oilersfan11]

Originally Posted by I am the Liquor

Musil. Easily.

How on earth did Marincin get in ahead of him?

http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/sh....php?t=1219559

[I am the Liquor]

Originally Posted by oilersfan11

http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/sh....php?t=1219559

Ya so?

If you think Marincin and Gernat are going to be better nhl players than Musil then you are misinformed.

[I am the Liquor]

Originally Posted by ManByng

@ I Am The Liquor....because Musil is seen as a bottom pairing d-man, whereas it is hoped Marincin will be a top 4.

Musil is going to be a shut down dman.

Derian Hatcher style.

Was Derian Hatcher a bottom pairing dman?

[oilersfan11]

Originally Posted by I am the Liquor

Ya so?

If you think Marincin and Gernat are going to be better nhl players than Musil then you are misinformed.

I'm not here to argue who should be ahead of someone,The MAJORITY of people think Marincin will be better.So I am going to post what these results show.

[I am the Liquor]

Originally Posted by oilersfan11

I'm not here to argue who should be ahead of someone,The MAJORITY of people think Marincin will be better.So I am going to post what these results show.

I wouldnt expect you to do anything else.

Just adding my two cents is all.

[gooilgo]

Martindale with another vote. Welcome to hf Mrs Martindale.

[CupofOil]

Gernat is really overrated IMO. He has a ton of work defensively to even make it to the NHL at all one day. His stats look inflated because of the team he was on IMO.
I would even rank Musil over him who is almost a shoe in to be an NHLer in some capacity IMO and likely a 2nd pairing guy.

Pitlick is the #4 prospect, he's almost NHL ready and has a good deal of upside.
Bunz would be #5 but goalies are always difficult to project.

[thadd]

Originally Posted by Mr Forever

Why aren't Lander or Hartikianen on this

Yeah, what you said.

I'll go with Gernat, Pitlick then Lander.

[misfit]

I wouldn't put him ahead of Marincin at this point, but I think Musil is very underrated on this board (and HF in general).

Voted Bunz though. This was a tough one for me.

[Brewster]

Rieder, 40+ goals in the OHL. If the guy turns out he could be exactly the secondary scoring this team needs.

[ManByng]

Originally Posted by ManByng

@ I Am The Liquor....because Musil is seen as a bottom pairing d-man, whereas it is hoped Marincin will be a top 4.

[/QUOTE]Musil is going to be a shut down dman

Derian Hatcher style.

Was Derian Hatcher a bottom pairing dman?[/QUOTE]

i'm just going by the massive amount of info i have read on Musil...likely a bottom pairing d-man with potential to be top 4. we can only hope he turns into a Derian Hatcher type.

[thadd]

I think it's safe to say that we've got a number of underrated prospects because we've been drafting early for a number of years now.

I agree Musil has good upside.

Pitlick and Hamilton have tons of upside.

Gernat just needs to put some meat on his bones and he'll be a beast.

Roy had a turn around year and Bunz had a great year.

Rieder scored a tons of goals.

[SK13]

Tough call between Reider and Gernat for me.

Think Gernat is a better prospect than Marincin, though.

[Jepprey]

Originally Posted by I am the Liquor

Musil. Easily.

How on earth did Marincin get in ahead of him?

I myself am surprised with all the Gernat love over most players. He's become really overrated around here.