You mean the teams the played on? Yeah, not even close to comparable.
Salary is pretty closely linked to stats in the NHL.
Dubnyk doesn't have the stats. Goalies on bad teams have put up good numbers in the past. If Dubnyk's stats were better, the team would have finished higher in the standings, then there wouldn't be a team excuse.
I don't see any reason why the Oilers should fork over big dollars. None.
I wouldn't pay him more than 1.5m per season until he actually proves he's a legit NHL goalie. After watching him play based on the first two-thirds of last season, I'd let him walk. His final third of last season looked solid. That being said.. I'm just not a Dubz fan and have zero faith in his game.