Redden's and Phillips' faces are set farther back in the mountain, because they had to chip out Yashin and Heatley's faces and replace them.
Not that anyone would carve such a monument today, but if you go with the old Ottawa hockey club the faces might be
Also considered Harvey Pulford, Clint Benedict, Cy Denneny, and Buck Boucher. Went with Gerard over Boucher, Benedict, and Denneny because he was team captain for many years, including the dynasty years.
then in the little known Hall of Records located just behind the carved faces of Mount Rushmore, Keon, Sittler, Horton, Bower, Salming, Kelly, Shack, Gilmour, Baun, Stanley, Clark, Joseph, Sundin, Potvin... MacDonald, Palmateer... and a few more.