Why does it have to be either, 1) Holmgren stupid, Gillis genius or 2) Holmgren genius, Gillis stupid?
Holmgren's offersheet was well thought out and it was worth a try. Gillis had a feeling it wouldn't work. Neither of these two GM's have lost or gained anything.. So why is either parties getting bashed/praised?
Both of them were smart for doing what they did/tried to do.