Really depends on the type of player you're looking for. If you're looking for a shutdown, physical guy, it's Backes easily. If you want more of an offensive minded guy with slick hands, it's Benn easily. If I only got one player for this year only, I'd want Backes. He's certainly competent offensively, good for 25-30-55 more than likely, and he plays Selke caliber defense. Benn's going to outscore Backes, but I think Backes's defense puts him over the top right now. Certainly wouldn't mind having either one though.