What do you all think would be accurate ratings? Without being homers.
I mean I have no big problems with the Avs rating except that Olver obviously lower to 74, Rob 2 higher to 78 and Varly to 83 and Jiggy to 77, Jones to 80 and Kobasew down to 74.
That's -9 for Olver, +2, +2, +1, +2 for the four and -4 for Koby.
You could perhaps tweak here and there something else as well, maybe put Downie down to 80 and PAP down to 80 as well or something like that.
For Avs Rankings I think that would be fairly accurate.
I actually think the Avs are done quite well except for Olver and the Goalies (which IMO are undervalued but maybe I'm just overrating them?)
For the others I obviously can't say very much, but Vancouver is really messed up with Hamhuis+Edler+Kesler at 88, Luongo at 89 and Schneider at 83.
Also Vokoun/Fleury having 87,87 and Miller at 92 are ridiculous according to the last 2 years from them all. (though Staz is a bit high then as well, maybe 84 for Staz?) Also Gagne is apparently as good as Kopitar?
Wow those are some of the worst ratings I have ever seen. Ever.
Actually majority of the players got smurfed in ratings. If you have ever played FIFA 12 only 3-4 players are rated higher then 90s. And think about how many more pro soccer players there are compared to hockey.
I'm very sure that a lot of those players potentials are really good. Only one I dislike is McGinns.