Voted Stamkos. 60 goals is such an impressive feat. How many guys have done that in the past 15 to 20 years? While Karlsson's season was indeed impressive, the kind of points he put up from the blueline isn't quite as ... unique as that of a 60 goal forward.
Voted Karlsson. It's just so impressive for a dman to do that at his age. Maybe if it weren't for Crosby and Ovy coming into the league and doing what they've done at such a young age I would vote Stamkos. I don't know, close poll and you can't go wrong either way. Stamkos definitely buries his chances in the games I've seen but doesn't really control the ice the way several other young players that I've watched do (Giroux, Tavares, Doughty, Karlsson etc.)