Trade Rumors and Free Agent TalkTrade rumors, transactions, and free agent talk. Rumors must contain the word RUMOR in post title. Proposals must contain the word PROPOSAL in post title.
Montreal gets a solid number one that can creat something and help score some more goals, Colarado clears the jam at center and get a guy who can fit right in at the third center position.
-
To Montréal:
Niklas Hjalmarsson
3rd 2013
To Chicago:
Thomas Plekanec
Chicago gets there number 2/3 Center and Habs get good young Dman to add to the back end.
-
To Calgary:
Chris Campoli
Jared Tinordi
3rd 2014,2016
To Montreal:
Jay Bouwmeester
Pat Sieloff
-
To Montreal:
Mark Vlasic
Ryane Clowe
To Sharks:
Josh Gorges
Rene Bourque
4th 2014
Montreal get solid Number 1/2 LW and get a solid Dman that's a hometown kid and would hopefully flourish here, San Jose Gets a great Defensive Defensman and a gritty number three LW.
To NYI:
Weber
To Montreal:
2nd 2014
-
To Columbus;
Diaz
To Montreal:
Prout
POSSIBLE LINE COMBO'S:
1st: Cole-Stastney-Gionta
2nd: Clowe-Leblanc-Pacioretty
3rd: Moën-Desharnais-Armstrong
4th-Prust-Gomez/Nokelanen-White
Defense:
1st: Bouwmeester-Subban
2nd:Hjarmalsson-Markov
3rd: Vlasic-Emelin
7th Dman:Kaberle/Bouillon
Goalies:
1st: Carey Price
2ndeter Budaj
Last edited by Spitsfan67: 09-03-2012 at 01:49 AM.
Calgary, Colorado, and San Jose all say "No". I doubt Montreal even considers the Chicago one. I don't have enough knowledge of Columbus or the Islanders to call those ones. Overall though, really brutal proposals.
Also, putting Vlasic as the 7th D-man shows you have zero idea what his true value is.
Last edited by spiny norman: 09-03-2012 at 11:27 AM.
Reason: not needed
Omg. I can't believe it but I found a proposal worse then some of the leafs one for staz. Eller does not solve **** for us. We need a defensemen to play with Johnson not another Center.
Montreal gets a solid number one that can creat something and help score some more goals, Colarado clears the jam at center and get a guy who can fit right in at the third center position.
Anyone else find this bit absolutely hilarious? He says we trade Stastny, and clear the logjam at center, but then trades us another center. And he also admits Montreal gets a #1 C while Colorado gets a 3rd line C...Yup, great logic there dude.
I don't think anyone can honestly think these are fair...
Last edited by spiny norman: 09-03-2012 at 11:28 AM.
Reason: not needed
Anyone else find this bit absolutely hilarious? He says we trade Stastny, and clear the logjam at center, but then trades us another center. And he also admits Montreal gets a #1 C while Colorado gets a 3rd line C...Yup, great logic there dude.
I don't think anyone can honestly think these are fair...
Dude. It totally makes sense. If we trade Stastny the logjam is gone. Eller is the 3rd line center, Mitchell 4th line center, ROR 2nd line center , Duchene 1st line center. Everyone has their position locked up and so the logjam is gone.
And we get (the value of) a 2nd for each line we downgrade. That totally makes sense. Stastny is a borderline #1 Center. For a 2nd we downgrade him to a #2 Center ( he could have given us Plekanec but getting Hjalmarsson is obv a priority) and than for another 2nd rnd pick in 2015 we downgrade that to a #3 Center in Eller. He is a better 3rd liner than Stastny is a #1 Center comparison wise. But that seems fair because the 2nd round pick is only in 2015. Inflation and everything you know.
I mean it is the same logic with Bozak and a 2nd. But Leafs fans don't get that there is another 2nd round pick missing in that proposal. But to be fair they usually make up for it by offering a few additional pieces of slightly not that great value.
But how can you say no to Bozak.
Though I don't know if that offer is still on the table. So for all means right now.
Yes from Colorado!
Last edited by spiny norman: 09-03-2012 at 11:28 AM.
Reason: qep
Dude. It totally makes sense. If we trade Stastny the logjam is gone. Eller is the 3rd line center, Mitchell 4th line center, ROR 2nd line center , Duchene 1st line center. Everyone has their position locked up and so the logjam is gone.
And we get (the value of) a 2nd for each line we downgrade. That totally makes sense. Stastny is a borderline #1 Center. For a 2nd we downgrade him to a #2 Center ( he could have given us Plekanec but getting Hjalmarsson is obv a priority) and than for another 2nd rnd pick in 2015 we downgrade that to a #3 Center in Eller. He is a better 3rd liner than Stastny is a #1 Center comparison wise. But that seems fair because the 2nd round pick is only in 2015. Inflation and everything you know.
I mean it is the same logic with Bozak and a 2nd. But Leafs fans don't get that there is another 2nd round pick missing in that proposal. But to be fair they usually make up for it by offering a few additional pieces of slightly not that great value.
But how can you say no to Bozak.
Though I don't know if that offer is still on the table. So for all means right now.
Yes from Colorado!
As a fan of both teams I can safely say that the Stastny deal is a clear no from Avs POV.
A moderator needs to lock this stupidity as soon as possible. As a Habs fan I am embarrassed by these "offers". Sorry to the fans of other teams about this crap.
eter Budaj
