This line-up will get slaughtered in the play-offs by the bigger, more physical teams.
Then what would your propose top 6 be?
Hall, Eberle, RNH, Hemsky, Yakupov are the given top 6. Hemsky is going no where and we need a 2C. Don`t tell me Hemsky will be gone because he`s gonna re-up this coming summer after he breaks out. Hemsky better get his 5yr deal.
Detroit always had a few bigger guys with top 6 skill-set: Franzen, Holmstrom, Samuelsson, Hossa etc.
None of whom (maybe Franzen, maybe) are remotely physical or intimidating to play against in terms of nastiness. They roast competition with creativity, pure drive and skill.
I bet you If the Oilers iced a top 6 like that they would absolutely dominate for stretches, while get bullied at other times. Not every team in the league is like the Bruins, Blues or Kings. Besides none of those guys are *******. They're tough enough. 5 man units and grit in your bottom six, good to go.