I've voted for Rooch since #3. Guy is right behind for me. Both of those guys made me love the game as a kid, and I happened to meet them both at Teemu's Poker Tourney a while back. They are both beauties and should be shown some love by the true Ducks faithful!
Voted for Getzlaf. Best center to ever suit up for the Ducks (well Oates had a better career but wasn't that player in Anaheim). Our current captain and member of the Stanley Cup Championship team. I'll probably vote Perry next, followed by Hebert, Rucchin, Pahlsson and Pronger to round out the top ten.
Lots of good choices here. Like Paul said, there's a few guys who are pretty equivalent. Actually before Kariya and Niedermayer in my book.
Pahlsson, Rucchin, Perry, and Hebert. Voted for Pahlsson, but I'd be happy with any of those guys.
Also I agree on Hebert's mask. It's also great how he used that design for so many years, unlike how Hiller and Giguere changed every year. I'm also partial to Giguere's Darkwing Duck pose mask, just because that's the one he wore in his big run.