I just made a Poll on the "mock draft" section of the forum. I will post here results and links of the poll in progress.
No Name % of vote(nb of vote)
1 Nathan Mackinnon 89% (24/27)
2 Seth Jones 81% (34/42)
3 Aleksandr S. Barkov 79% (37/47)
4 Sean Monahan 61% (17/28)
5 Elias Lindholm 43% (18/42)
6 Jonathan Drouin 46% (17/37)
A problem with this will be that voters dont see the players play live, and also are very influenced by hot streaks. For example, after the first week or so I saw several lists with Kujawinski in the top 10 after he won the first OHL player of the week. Likewise, many people were souring on Jones as a top 5 pick after his slow start.
I know that it could change alot, but I will probably do another one later, and yes people can judge players they have not seen but I just want to have a ranking about the "general consensus" of the population. More we have vote better it will be.