Schultz definitely looks better so far but Hamilton is younger so its tough to tell. Hamilton probably has a higher ceiling but not by much and I think Schultz has a much better chance of reaching it so I take him.
Hamilton put up big numbers in juniors. Schultz put up even bigger numbers in the AHL and is starting to carrying it over to the NHL. I'd take Schultz because I feel that Hamilton wont be at the level Schultz is at the same age.