I would say no. They're not terrible but that's pretty much the same as what the Oilers have now.
I don't want to sound like I'm picking on you but the 2006 version of Horcoff, Stoll and Peca was significantly better than RNH, Gagner and Horcoff.
In 2006 Horcoff had 71 points while Stoll had 68 points. Also, they both were great faceoff men and great defensively(as was Peca). Offensively, RNH is the only one that competes with them and defensively they were on a completely different level.