I would reserve this list for players who have actually done reprehensible **** like the first 9 guys. As much as I hate to play the race card, I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of people hate Subban because he's a flashy black player. There are plenty of flashy other guys in the league worse than PK.
Yeah this is the other part of it, why do players from other teams hate PK so much? He seems like a great guy off the ice, loves the game, and isn't a dirty player. It can't just be because he's not a robot like 90% of the league, can it?
On the contrary it is pretty much universally held that slough footing is a very dirty and cheap play. Subban has done it more then once or twice.
Honestly very surprised Doughty and Doan didn't make the list. They're both classless, play dirty, and are some of the biggest whiners in the NHL. Is it just their reputations that keep them off this list (Norris nominee, captain of a team)?