Who is your top 5 list of dirtiest players while you've been a fan?
We had the worst player in history thread and there were a lot of goons and repeat offenders listed to I figured it deserved it own thread.
My list is:
Dald Hunter - for obvious reasons
Old Matt Cooke - for obvious reasons
Kasparaitis - the reason a lot of older players have leg/ankle/knee/hip issues
Sean Avery - for obvious reasons
Chris Pronger - general dirtiness and dbaggery and the attempt to amputate Keslers leg
Honorable Mention: Derian Hatcher - his biggest asset was his ability to crosscheck
Hatcher wasn't even the dirtiest player on his team. His best asset was his shut down ability. Matvichuk was dirtier. Hatcher was just bigger and could deal out more punishing hits. Marchment gets my vote though, followed by pronger.
Steve Smith (not sure if he was actually dirty, but when i was a kid he ****ed up my favorite player's knee.)
Scott Stevens (what he did used to be legal, but I still think his hits were dirty.)