Fergy with his machine gun fists was a better fighter then most. Nilan was the Retaliator: you hurt my players, you pay the price. But the best one was the Butch: his presence alone did the job.
Once a Hab player lost a glove in a brawl and a Boston player took it and brought it back to the Boston's bench. The Butch went to the Boston's bench, opened the door, walked behind the bench past the coach, picked up the glove and brought it back, no questions asked by the Boston's players or coach. Never saw an enforcer inspire so much respect.
The best pure pugilist I've seen (as in, the art of throwing punches...) was Roberge. Not the best enforcer, though -- that title would go to John Ferguson.
Can't remember who said something about JF's size, or lack thereof...
The average player human being (and the average player as well) is taller and heavier nowadays. Le Gros Bill was 6'3 210 pounds or so, yet you keep seeing comments about how huge he was. 6'3 210 is good size nowadays, but you certainly wouldn't use the word "huge" to describe what is basically Max Pac or Rene Bourque in today's world.
Roberge I think was a case of either not having a great hockey QI or perhaps his coach was not using him well? Because it's strange that a guy like him who could play hockey and also was one of the best puncher had so little effects on a game.
Nilan or Larry Robinson. Ferguson I can remember but long, long time ago.
Probably Robinson. I can remember a bench clearing brawl with Philly when I was about 10 years old. I remember it was a Sunday afternoon. Habs weren't doing too well until Robinson came out of the dressing room and pummelled Schultz. That was pretty cool for 10 year old. Flyers at the time we nicknamed the broad street bullies. Widely considerated the toughest era in hockey. Schultz was reigning league heavy weight champ. After that they never dominated us physically.
Last edited by BrimStone64: 08-09-2013 at 08:39 PM.