This might literally be the 10th time this poll has been made since the season ended. Tavares usually wins to poll and then everyone who posts comes in to say he's not at Giroux's level JUST YET. And then after that it turns into a pissing match.
Can we just skip to the part where Flyers fans say that Tavares hasn't proven to be better than Giroux, while Isles fans insist that you need to watch Tavares play and that he would have way more points with better linemates?
Tavares has done absolutely nothing to surpass Giroux as of right now. Giroux had a "down year" last season and still had more points than JT. He's older and JT will be better in a few seasons, but right now there is no reason to pick Tavares, if we're talking about one season.