Trade Rumors and Free Agent TalkTrade rumors, transactions, and free agent talk. Rumors must contain the word RUMOR in post title. Proposals must contain the word PROPOSAL in post title.
Change McAmmond to something more worthwhile. Philly is essentially giving up Gagne, Richards, and Handzus for Iginla. McAmmond is not very valuable right now, and is hurt. Maybe Gauthier or Regher.
Change McAmmond to something more worthwhile. Philly is essentially giving up Gagne, Richards, and Handzus for Iginla. McAmmond is not very valuable right now, and is hurt. Maybe Gauthier or Regher.
Would conroy interest you. I heard that philly is stacked at D right now
to Edm: Gagne
to Cal: Comrie, Woywitka, Rita/Chimera
to Phil: Iginla
Calgary would obviously be reluctant to move their franchise player but they get back a goalscorer in Comrie and two blue chip prospects.. likewise, Rita/Chimera could likely crack their lineup as well and be good two-way players. Clarke obviously wouldn't be eager to move Gagne but he'd get back Iginla (someone he obviously has coveted) and only gives up Gagne and Woywitka.. any thoughts?
to Edm: Gagne
to Cal: Comrie, Woywitka, Rita/Chimera
to Phil: Iginla
Calgary would obviously be reluctant to move their franchise player but they get back a goalscorer in Comrie and two blue chip prospects.. likewise, Rita/Chimera could likely crack their lineup as well and be good two-way players. Clarke obviously wouldn't be eager to move Gagne but he'd get back Iginla (someone he obviously has coveted) and only gives up Gagne and Woywitka.. any thoughts?
We give up Gagne and Woywitka for Iginla? I'd do it.
to Edm: Gagne
to Cal: Comrie, Woywitka, Rita/Chimera
to Phil: Iginla
Calgary would obviously be reluctant to move their franchise player but they get back a goalscorer in Comrie and two blue chip prospects.. likewise, Rita/Chimera could likely crack their lineup as well and be good two-way players. Clarke obviously wouldn't be eager to move Gagne but he'd get back Iginla (someone he obviously has coveted) and only gives up Gagne and Woywitka.. any thoughts?
How 'bout giving Woywitka to Edmonton, dropping Rita, and moving Gagne to Calgary? Perhaps a high pick to Edmonton as well, in the upper second round.
I'd do it then. We don't really need Jeff, although getting him and Phaneuf together would be pretty sweet. (No Phaneuf for you, though! )
How 'bout giving Woywitka to Edmonton, dropping Rita, and moving Gagne to Calgary? Perhaps a high pick to Edmonton as well, in the upper second round.
I'd do it then. We don't really need Jeff, although getting him and Phaneuf together would be pretty sweet. (No Phaneuf for you, though! )
So are you saying Gagne and Comrie for Iginla? If so, no way will Iginla get that in return. Iginla is good, but not good enough to fetch two young forwards who have both already scored 30 goals.
So are you saying Gagne and Comrie for Iginla? If so, no way will Iginla get that in return. Iginla is good, but not good enough to fetch two young forwards who have both already scored 30 goals.
Likewise, the Oilers won't trade Comrie for Woywitka and a pick.. they need someone who can step in right now and make an impact. The only problem I see with my proposed deal is that Calgary would likely want more than Comrie, Woywitka and Rita for Iginla.. I personally don't think the value is that far off however.
I think Iginla is worth both of those players, salary aside, quite easily.
I agree that he is possibly worth both Comrie and Gagne.. not "easily" however. Both Gagne and Comrie are 30 goal scorers and Iginla has not done much to prove his one season was more of a fluke than a standard. If I was the GM of a team with both Gagne and Comrie on the roster, I personally wouldn't trade them both away for Iginla...
)
I think Iginla is worth both of those players, salary aside, quite easily.
