I'm undecided on Kariya. I would love to have him back, but I would rather resign Hartnell if push comes to shove. Kariya's play here has been outstanding through almost the entirety of his two regular seasons, and he has had one great playoff series along with one bad playoff series....I think any team that signs him will get a very good player, albeit more of a playmaker than goal-scorer at this point in his career.
On the one hand if he leaves good luck to him he was great for us minus the last 25 or so games of his second year, he played every game for us. Was crucial in the shootout, and late in games especially early in season 2 and was our best player in the playoffs 2 seasons ago. Not only that but he was instrumental in gaining us interest from other free agents that arrived here during his stay (Dumont, Arnott).
On the other hand if he stays i would not say no, realistically he should have much more to offer and i wouldn't say no to someone who WANTS to play for Nashville (yes Hartnell I am talking to you...).