He is not God as this board makes him out to be. A very good player yes, but after winning the cup he's gotten really overrated on these boards. Same thing happened with Getzlaf last year.
Actually i'd probably change my vote from Zetterberg to Campbell now that I think about it.
I think both are overrated, Zetterberg is going to get my vote though because he is viewed as a top 3-5 talent in the NHL and while he is great i dont think he is that good, i think he benefits as much from the system as the system benefits from him. All of the players listed were in my opinion underrated.
And my answers are... Alfredsson, Sundin, Carter, Richards, and I hate to say it, but Brown
Do you ever even watch the Sens play? The guy is arguably the hardest working player in the league. He does absolutely everything for the Sens. He can score, pass, skate, defend and kill penalties....Alfredsson is underrated not overrated. And when people say that Spezza and Heatley are the best players on the Sens, there wrong. It's Alfredsson. I wish the Oilers had a player half of what Alfredsson is.
I think Malkin is a tad overrated. I only need to read one of the many threads about him where countless people said he is the best player on his team. The same said he's better than AO. He is not the best player in hockey. Top 10 no doubt , but not even close to as good as AO or Crosby.