Thomas Vanek vs Patrick Kane

[GIN ANTONIC]

Originally Posted by Buffalofan84

with any real first line center he easily would hit 60 ...

roy and hecht are 2nd or 3rd liners.

Derek Roy is an excellent 2nd line capable and a capable 1st line player. Hecht is another story but I wouldn't use the 'linemate excuse' on this one.

[Dr Grant]

Very Close, but i'd slightly take Vanek, just because we could use a sniper like him on the Devils.

[ugotmybeef*]

Vanek, only if he had someone else to bury the puck with him.

[BackGroundMusic]

I'd like them on the same line, please.

[MayDay]

Originally Posted by BikeGiftingMan

I'd like them on the same line, please.

How bout a line of Toews centering Kane and Vanek?

That would be awesome. One Canadian + One American + One Euro = lots of scoring.

In response to the question, I'd give a slight edge to Kane, even though I'm a Sabres fan. The fact that Kane has already done so much at his young age makes me think that he's a very special player.

But don't get me wrong, I'm thrilled with what Vanek has been doing this season. He's making a strong case that he should be counted among the top 10 forwards in the NHL.

[pouskin74*]

Kane

[Habs 4 Life]

Vanek,we need someone that can score goals right now!!