Quote:
Originally Posted by zyllyx
Not surprising since Bud Selig makes Gary Bettman look like a prince.
|
This. I am not a big Bettman fan, but at least he's not singlehandedly ruining baseball like Selig has been doing.
Anyway, back to the OP. If the NHL stays with its current 6-division system, which it probably will, here's one possible setup. My thinking was to, in this order, (1) Reduce the range of intra-division time zones, which is a MAJOR problem in the Western Conference, (2) Preserve local rivalries, and (3) minimize intra-division travel distance. So do the following moves:
PHX HAM-> Atl
BOS -> SE (the hardest of the moves to figure out; see below)
ATL -> Cent. (see below why I think it may work)
CHI -> NW
DAL -> NW (time zone issue)
VAN -> Pac.
COL -> Pac.
and you get:
==========
WEST
Pacific:
SJ
LA
ANA
COL
VAN
Northwest:
CGY
EDM
MIN
DAL
CHI
Central:
DET
CLB
NAS
STL
ATL
EAST
Atlantic:
HAM (Hamilton)
TOR
MON
OTT
BUF
Northeast:
NYI
NYR
NJ
PHI
PIT
Southeast:
TB
FLA
CAR
BOS
WAS
==========
Due to its sheer east-west distance, the PHX->Hamilton move would create havoc for divisional alignments. If it was something simpler, such as PHX->Winnipeg, they could just move that team into the Northwest and move Vancouver into the Pacific to compensate. But unfortunately, the NHL is gonna have to move teams all over the place to compensate. Placing us in the Central would at least give us two other Eastern-Time divisional opponents. It would also open a rivalry with Nashville. The biggest drawback would be all those late-night games on the West Coast, something I do not look forward to.
That leaves all the other moves to do...
I just can't see Pittsburgh wanting to leave the Atlantic. Even if it means being with Detroit, the long-standing intrastate rivalry with Philly is probably going to be too much for them to depart. Since this puts three Canadian teams in one division, and a fourth city (Buffalo) is right nearby, the odd city out is Boston. So send them to the Southeast. Then swap some teams around the Pacific and Northwest, and the changes are complete.
ALTERNATIVELY, there's another way to not have this mess in the East: Send Pittsburgh to the Central and Philly to the Southeast. Don't know how well that would go over, though.
Again, I would rather not leave the East. But with the exception of some of the West teams' moves, this is closer to what I *think* would happen, not what I *want* to happen.