Salo/Mitchell/Bieksa/Edler or Kaberle/Komisarek/Beauchemin/Schenn?

[Lundface]

Edler>Schenn

Mitchell> Komisarik

Bieksa<<Kaberle

Salo> Beachemin

The only thing keeping this so close is the fact that Kaberle is leaps and bounds better than Bieksa, and Salo is injury prone.

On a side note, how many teams in the NHL have 3 guys on the point who can shoot harder than 102 MPH ? ( Salo, Edler, Ohlund last year)

[Schenn]

Schenn has more potential than all players in their prime,
Kaberle is one of the top 5 best puck movers in the game at the moment,
Beachemin is just plain better than Bieksa
Komisarek is much more effective than Mithcell



IMO

[King Canuck]

Originally Posted by schenn29

Schenn has more potential than all players in their prime,
Kaberle is one of the top 5 best puck movers in the game at the moment,
Beachemin is just plain better than Bieksa
Komisarek is much more effective than Mithcell



IMO

[The Stovepipe Cup]

Originally Posted by schenn29

Schenn has more potential than all players in their prime,
Kaberle is one of the top 5 best puck movers in the game at the moment,
Beachemin is just plain better than Bieksa
Komisarek is much more effective than Mithcell



IMO

These two are definite NO's.
And Schenn having potential is a moot point when it's about who would you rather have now
Kaberle is arguable but it's the closest thing to reality you posted.