I attended one playoff game this season and I was lucky enough to have a great view of that move, albeit in an upper section. It was an unbelievable feeling (funny, I saw his pass/spin off the boards move too - not a STH).
Unfortunately that was an ESPY, which means hockey never wins. That could have been in triple OT in game 7 of the cup finals, and it still wouldn't have won. Football will always take those multi-sport awards, and that one was in the super bowl, making it an easier pick.