The rest of the playoff results:
5. Mark Pavelich
7. In the Hall
8. Draft Guru
9. Fire Sather
Thanks to everyone involved. This was a pretty good league that didn't need much commishing. We'll do this again on Yahoo next year (assuming there is a next year) unless anyone knows of a free service that lets you do keeper fantasy leagues.
You probably already know this but, if you want to do a free keeper league in Yahoo, just have everyone submit to the commish the players they are keeping (however many you decide beforehand). Then just do a manual off-line draft next year and enter the keepers in manually. this is how my friends and I did it...worked out great. Of course, you have to have an "Offline" draft and that may not be feesable in your situation.