imo I think Carcillo is one of the better players in 2nd period.
i agree. i think the "problem" with carcillo is his volatility. as with someone like downie, when harnessed correctly it's an asset. he's still got some maturing to do, and he's very unpredictable, but when he's on his game, he's actually a pretty good guy to have on your team. i really like powe, though. if it came down to the two of them, i think i'd have to go with powe.