Since, as you said, Ramsay's Selke was more of a life-time acheivement award, only 3 players haver won the Selke without meeting the criteria I laid out?
It hasn't been good for rewarding unsung heros... because it waits for them to put up career offensive numbers before they get the award.
An undrafted player won it with 8g, 17a his 2nd to last year in the league so he would qualify. Another undrafted player won it with a 40 point year, though he had 24 goals. Another undrafted player won it with a 38 point year. Dirk Graham won it with a 54 point year in 89-90 which is a pretty piddling total for a guy playing as much as he did at the time.
If you're looking for a Blair Betts guy with no offensive game to speak of, I think the 8g 17a guy qualifies.
I have to head out, and I probably won't be back until after the Sask. Roughriders game this afternoon. So I'm going to have to create the new draft thread a little early, since we know how some of you guys can talk.