Is Curtis Joseph a Hall of Fame goaltender?

[Telos]

Rogie Vachon achieved more, including multiple Stanley Cup rings, a Vezina Trophy, and finished in the top 5 all-time wins (I think third) at the time of his retirement and he never made it to the Hall of Fame...

I would say that CuJo never makes it.

[Vinnie]

Generally I think if you have to ask the answer is no.

[WingsFan95]

Inclined to say yes, but he's in a backlog of more deserving candidates.

His 16 playoff shutouts is in my opinion his biggest accomplishment.

However I'd probably put The Beezer in before him.

[5RingsAndABeer]

Wins are such an overrated stat for goalies.

Great goalies sometimes are stuck on bad teams, while mediocre goalies can get lots of wins on great teams.

[211*]

hell no he was always overrated

[whatthef]

Welcome to the Hall of Very Good

[MastuhNinks]

Originally Posted by WatchaMaCarcass

If you're talking statistics, being first (or tied for first) in all time losses is a definite strike against.

Does it? You don't get to the most losses of all time unless you're a good goalie. I mean obviously it sounds bad but for a goalie to be played that much says something.