Since these polls always come down to what have you done for me lately, it is of no surprise to me that Kipper is winning. I personally feel Henrik is the better goaltender but this year, there is no question as to whom is having the better year. It's Kipper.
Gotta be Kipper. I love Henrik, he's been great for us since his rookie season, but the last 2+ seasons he really has not been elite. Kipper struggled immensely the last couple years as well, but seems to be back to form. Both in terms of career accomplishments and this current year it's hard not to go with Mikka. If Henrik can get some consistency, and work on his glove hand he has the potential to be better, but as of right now I think he's overrated and only considered elite because of his first 2 seasons in the league, rather than his 3 most recent ones.