I thought this was going to either be about a steel-cage death match, or whose foot injuries are worse. I'll give Carter the edge in foot injuries, but Gagne the edge in the steel-cage. The match would start with Carter taking some long strides around Gagne and checking him from behind. Gags would then go all ape**** on his ass like he did Volchenkov.
If Jeff Carter plays the same amount of games as gagne in a flyers jersey he will become a great. His wrist shot alone is probably the best in the league. That alone will give him 30 goals a year, every year. Carter also has a very underrated defensive game, Gagne allthough very good defensivly i think is a little overrated