Gagné vs Carter

[Ziostilon]

Probably not the best poll question to ask at this time of the year.
However, greatness is defined during this time of the year.

With that said, Who do you believe will be the better player of all-time?
Jeff Carter or Simon Gagné

[Juicy Couturier*]

Those chicks are nasty.

[SolidSnakeUS]

Honestly, if I had anyone in a Flyers uniform since the lock out to rely on, I would have to say Gagne by a LONG shot.

[Valhoun*]

Right now? Gags. In the future? Carter. Carter will score at least 100 more goals than Gagne in his career.

[agrudez*]

Richards.

[RIPRichardsCarter]

Gagne now, but ask me again in 2 years and it will be Carter.

[Giroux tha Damaja]

Originally Posted by CannonGoBoom

Those chicks are nasty.

So it's Carter then?

[claude boivin lives]

I thought this was going to either be about a steel-cage death match, or whose foot injuries are worse. I'll give Carter the edge in foot injuries, but Gagne the edge in the steel-cage. The match would start with Carter taking some long strides around Gagne and checking him from behind. Gags would then go all ape**** on his ass like he did Volchenkov.

[JCameron418]

Carcillo

[fire bettman]

Right now, obviously Gagne has accomplished more.... down the line I think Carter will put up more points so I voted Carter which was very hard for me to do because I love Gags.

[Spongolium*]

If Jeff Carter plays the same amount of games as gagne in a flyers jersey he will become a great. His wrist shot alone is probably the best in the league. That alone will give him 30 goals a year, every year. Carter also has a very underrated defensive game, Gagne allthough very good defensivly i think is a little overrated